Sunday, September 9, 2012

Taboo Topics in YA Literature + Sweetest Taboo Giveaway!

Explicit sex. Drug-use. Severe violence. These are the top three taboo subjects, in my opinion, which many YA enthusiasts prefer not to see in what is perceived to be a ‘light hearted’ genre for older children and adults. In essence, these can be considered taboo subjects by many YA lit lovers; however, there are YA consumers that are more tolerant of serious and ‘real life’ subject matter in the YA genre. Let’s demystify the explicit sex taboo in YA literature first.
Many YA readers believe that explicit sex should not be included in YA lit and if it is included then the inclusion of such a subject renders the book adult literature. The nature of the sex is important. For instance, my debut novel Sweetest Taboo does not include overly graphic sex scenes but does include one or two instances where a sexual encounter is described tastefully. Nevertheless, some YA readers feel that the type of sex, in this case sex between a student and a teacher, will dictate the genre of the book. I, however, disagree. My experience with YA literature extends back to the mid-80s when I began devouring the VC Andrews Flower in the Attic series. I was perhaps 13 at the time and reading what was then considered YA literature, a series of books that included sex between a brother and sister. The scenes were not overly graphic, but as a 13 year old I was definitely aware of what was being described in the book. I firmly believe that if sex is treated realistically and tastefully in a book that is YA classified (i.e. a book that is written from the perspective and voice of a young adult/teen), then explicit sex should cease to be considered a taboo topic in YA lit.
As for drug-use and severe violence, many believe these should not be included in YA lit and if included, again, the book ceases to exist in the YA genre and should be classified as adult fiction. As I’ve argued in several other posts, young adults (primarily those 14 and older) are exposed to many of these taboo topics in their day-to-day lives. Young adults are faced with many unpleasant situations in their lives. Teens may have friends with drug-abuse problems, or they know someone that was depressed and attempted suicide, maybe they have friends who have been molested, raped, or physically abused by relatives or boyfriends. Sheltering young adults from literature that contains mature subject matter is not doing them a service, but rather these young adults miss out on the opportunity to learn about how others address these difficult issues in their lives, how they cope, how they seek help and how they overcome obstacles. Life is not always as pleasant as we would like and by providing young adults with realistic literary content, teens venture beyond vampires and fairy tales to learn how to cope with life’s trials and tribulations, and also learn from the mistakes characters make throughout any given story. In Sweetest Taboo we learn where Isabel went astray, we see the exact choices she made that sent her down a very dangerous path. In She’s Come Undone, we learn to recognize the signs of eating disorders and the importance of self-worth. There are so many rich lessons to be learned in our young literary journeys, why limit the opportunities of self-discovery by labeling mature content as taboo?
What do you think? I’d love to hear your thoughts!


Debby said...

I tend to agree. Violence, sex, and drug use should not be in a YA novel. If it is then who can it be YA? That would take out the distinction between YA and adult books. I am not fond of student teacher relationships on a HS or lower level.
debby236 at gmail dot com

Molly said...

In a YA novel, if the author is showing the right from the wrong with the drugs and violence it MAY be okay...but it they are approving the drugs and violence, no. No way. As for the sex, definitely not in a YA novel because that is saying it's okay no matter the age when it's not. As for what Debby said, I agree...student/teacher relationship in anything less than college level ultimately shouldn't happen. I think 18+ college level student/teacher relationships would be okay if the circumstances were right.

molly at reviewsbymolly dot com

Catherine Lee said...

I'm a librarian at a community college. We have a YA collection to promote high interest recreational reading for our "Young Adults." Most of these students are adults--17 to 21 years of age. We include "Urban Fiction" in this area--which has its share of sex, drugs, gangs, and violence. The books are very popular and it gets kids reading and thinking. Having such content in books does not promote sex, drug use and's just a mirror to the experiences of today's youth.
catherinelee100 at gmail dot com